Book Review: The Thirteenth Tale

A Brilliant Debut Novel by Diane Setterfield

36 Comments
Join the Conversation
The Thirteenth Tale - Courtesy of Simon and Schuster
The Thirteenth Tale - Courtesy of Simon and Schuster
If you read just one mystery novel this season -- or this year -- make it "The Thirteenth Tale" by Diane Setterfield.

This rich, multi-layered Gothic tale, in the tradition of Daphne DuMaurier and the Bronte sisters, grabs the reader from the first pages and doesn't let go.

"Do You Intend to Tell Me the Truth?"

The Thirteenth Tale is the story of Vida Winter, a best-selling British writer nearing the end of her life, and Margaret Lea, the youngish apprentice bookseller and part-time biographer, whom Ms. Winter has chosen to write her life story. The problem is that Ms. Winter has spent her life telling stories -- including 19 different ones about her background and childhood. Will she be able to tell the truth this time?

The Thirteenth Tale

The Thirteenth Tale is, of course, Ms. Winter's final tale. As it unfolds, the reader meets a troubled family, right out of the pages of Jane Eyre or Wuthering Heights, and a crumbling Gothic mansion called Anglefield, reminiscent of Rebecca's Manderley. There is a secret garden, confused identities, and tragedy, all in the Gothic tradition. But, although this novel pays homage to those great novels that came before, it stands well on its own. To add another layer, Margaret has ghosts of her own, ghosts that are awakened as she hears Ms. Winter's story.

The Forgotten Craft of a Well-Written Novel

It's hard to believe that The Thirteenth Tale is a first novel. The prose is rich and nuanced and the grammar is perfect -- a rarity these days. The frustrated English major in me really shouldn't be bothered when other authors miss the subjunctive "were" for "was" -- or "whom" for "who" – or even "that" for "which", but how delightful it is to read a novel where all of these grammatical subtleties are respected.

The Thirteenth Tale is a wonderful and unexpected surprise. If you're a fan of DuMaurier, Bronte, Dickens, or even Agatha Christie, you're sure to enjoy this novel.

About Diane Setterfield

From the back cover of the book: Diane Setterfield is a former academic, specializing in 20th French literature. She lives in Yorkshire, England.

Book Club Discussion Questions for The Thirteenth Tale

Looking for discussion questions about The Thirteenth Tale for your book club? Take advantage of these questions by Erin Miller, from About.com's Bestsellers site. Spoiler Alert: The questions contain information about the plot and ending of the novel. Click here for the questions.

Sandy Mitchell, <i>(© 2005 Terry Michelle)</i>

Sandy Mitchell - Sandy Mitchell is a fulltime freelance writer, based in Cleveland Ohio. Her passion for reading began as early as she could hold a book ...

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 0+8?
36 Comments

Comments

May 4, 2008 3:30 PM
Guest :
AMAZING BOOK!!!!!!!!!!
and this is a first?
there is no way.
May 9, 2008 2:53 PM
Guest :
the thirteenth tale was a wonderful story. beautifully written and leaves the reader wanting more and waiting for next novel by this author. Just when I thought a good read was gone along comes this great book. My copy is now in mississauga and from there will find Montreal and last but not least Calgary. Joyce
May 14, 2008 8:44 AM
Guest :
I have been trying to get into the novel and find it difficult because the author seems to put style over substance. It is beautifully written, but the excessive descriptions and foreshadowing tend to slow down the movement . I like a novel that moves the plot and character and keeps the detail in the background.
Aug 18, 2008 10:18 AM
Guest :
i thought the book was great i never guessed the twist, we are doing the book for our book club. cindy in woodland hills
Aug 27, 2008 10:35 PM
Guest :
I thought the book was great - very readable. However, i did find the main protagonist, Margaret, to be extremely melodramatic. I understand it was meant to be a gothic novel, but i still found her 'voice' to be irritating in the extreme. It was only because Vida's story was so enthralling that i continued reading and forced myself to put up with Margaret.
Aug 30, 2008 1:04 PM
Guest :
I agree. Totally amazing book. I cannot put this book down!! I am huge reader and read everything I can get my hands on. I never buy too many books because it's done in such a short time I'd spend a fortune. Only those I REALLY like do I purchase for my collection. I want this one. This is one of the best fiction books I have ever read.

I too cannot believe this is a first novel. I want more!!!
Sep 9, 2008 10:36 AM
Guest :
I think it's pretty good so far. it's sorta easy to relate to the whole love of books thing.
Sep 28, 2008 1:02 PM
Guest :
Excellent! First great fiction novel I've read in a couple of years. So great that when I googled Diane Setterfield and learned she has no other published works I was greatly disappointed. I will surely keep an eye out for any future publication to her credit.
Nov 16, 2008 6:53 PM
Guest :
wow!
i have read the book lately!!
its nice!
i have not thought that it suits my reading standard!
try it guys!!
Nov 16, 2008 6:56 PM
Guest :
wow!
i have read the book lately!!
its nice!
i have not thought that it suits my reading standard!
try it guys!!
Nov 19, 2008 11:48 AM
Guest :
By far the BEST book I have ever read. I cannot wait for another one by Ms. Setterfield.
Nov 30, 2008 4:04 AM
Guest :
This Book is truly amazing. Any reader would want to read it again. I am truly fascinated about the words that was written on The Thirttenth Tale. This book tells a story about twins and I tell you that it may be confusing as you read the part about mysteries, but if you read the whole story you will be surprised and I think you guys will also feel emotional because it is truly a beautiful story. I am looking forward for another book that is truly beautiful as this one and I have to say Ms. Setterfield that you are truly a smart woman because of this talent of yours and I have to say that keep it up and never quit (give up). THANKS A LOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Nov 30, 2008 4:06 AM
Guest :
What a beautiful story this book is.
Dec 29, 2008 12:25 AM
Guest :
THIS BOOK?........JUST AMAZING......
I LOVE IT.........
FANTASTIC EVER I SEEN
Jan 8, 2009 12:45 PM
Guest :
After reading The Thirteenth Tale, I became intrigued with the term "'gothic". The story in this novel is, indeed, gothic. The stories (and there are several on-going at any one time) are full of strong emotions and apprehension. I loved the way that Setterfield was able to offer the reader threads of information and, then, make sure that everything was tied up neatly at or near the end. She created an atmosphere of suspense and a feeling of uneasiness for me, the reader. I look forward to another novel by this author.
Jan 22, 2009 3:10 AM
Guest :
A friend of mine lent me 'The Thirteenth Tale', and I fell completely in love with it. Couldn't put it down! Apart from *The Shadow Of The Wind', no book has made me feel so sad, happy and excited all at once!
Aina
Feb 7, 2009 11:35 PM
Guest :
I just love a book every now and then that I cannot put down and this was one of them. I would wake up in the middle of the night to see what was happening.
ab
Mar 9, 2009 4:51 PM
Guest :
While the settings were so rich in detail, I found the characters
lacking beyond being outlined. I never felt empathetic or sympathetic toward any of the characters. I thought that the descriptions of the setting were redundant and therefore prohibited the book from taking on any type of a forward rhythm.
Karin
Mar 10, 2009 7:18 AM
Guest :
The audio version of this book is outstanding.
Mar 28, 2009 5:25 PM
Guest :
The audiobook version is amazing!
Mar 31, 2009 1:17 PM
Guest :
I am having a very difficult time with this book as it is moving painfully slow at the beginning. We are reading it for book club too, and I sincerely hope my perseverance is paid off as richly as the glowing comments below would suggest.
May 22, 2009 3:23 PM
Guest :
It's not that good, honestly. And this from someone who loves Gothic novels. I forced myself to keep reading to the end. It was mildly entertaining but no more than that. Don't believe the hype.
Jun 13, 2009 11:25 PM
Guest :
This book was AMAZING!!! It was the best book i've read in a long time. My sister borrowed it from her school library, and as I could not find it anywhere, i had to sneak it out and keep reading behind her back. I'm glad i did, as i could barely put it down. Definetly a thumbs up for this book. =)
Jul 12, 2009 11:40 AM
Guest :
Having just voraciously devoured this tale, I cannot imagine that any adjectives that I might use would sufficiently express my tremendous delight in it. I am certain that other readers of this novel responded as strongly to it as I have. The story itself is so wonderfully presented and in such perfect grammar that it resonates in ways that the writings of the Brontes and others continue to resonate with us. My only wish is that Daine Setterfield will use her incredible talents to delight us with many more tales in the future. Martha
Aug 17, 2009 9:51 PM
Guest :
I have never read a book that brought tears to my eyes when I finished it until this one (Read 2 - 3 books a week, all kinds, 43 yrs old). Never have I read a book that had such an complete ending that answered questions I didn't even know I needed. Nothing is more frustrating than a well written book/story line that ends with things unanswered or unexplained! This is a keeper, and am NOT loaning it out to anyone...they can get their own!! Incredible writing!!! My new all time favorite!
Sep 29, 2009 6:11 AM
Guest :
im gonna read this tale for the 13th time
Dec 1, 2009 11:17 PM
Guest :
I have read about half of this book and while I am persevering out of curiosity to learn the big "secret' I am promised will shock, amaze and enthrall me, I have to say the voice of the writer is very annoying, and character is is just not credible; the sharpening of the pencils makes me feel a world away from her... she is way too melodramatic for my comfort and I want tso slap her and give her a biro if not a a laptop.
Julie.
Feb 21, 2010 12:09 AM
Guest :
I thought this book was brilliant. Beautifully written and the plot kept me guessing to the very end. This is one that will stand out as one of the best I've read for many years.
Feb 26, 2010 10:25 AM
Guest :
I LOVED the book- it is one of the best I have read in a long time and I read ALOT of books. I thought it was amazing and the ending was something I was not expecting. Fantastic and I will be looking for more books by Diane Setterfield. (to those who had a hard time getting into it, I don't understand why not- try re-reading it)
Mar 21, 2010 10:44 AM
Guest :
I loved this book. I read it a few years ago and I still think about it. I have borrowed it to friends, no one has not enjoyed it. I recently reread it and loved it all over again.
I want more. I really wish Diane Setterfield would write more books.
Mar 23, 2010 5:57 PM
Guest :
I loved this book, I thought the setting brought back childhood memories, and the mystery at the end was quite unexpected. Our book club has been reading a lot of survival novels, and this was just the sort of novel to change the tone.
Apr 23, 2010 7:00 AM
Guest :
great book... one of the best and this is her first book???
amazing
Aug 4, 2010 11:22 PM
Guest :
This book was SICK. AHHH. It was mindblowing. I'm actually a little confused now because I went through it so fast! ABout the ending when she keeps saying "the one referred to as Emmeline" as if Emmeline was not really Emmeline?! I'm confused there!
Oct 10, 2010 12:42 PM
Guest :
OMG! This book moved me so much, as i have a twin sister who died during surgery too! The book itself is amazing with many stories and unexpected twists which fit like a puzzle at the end. I look forward to more books by Diane Setterfield. I can NOT believe that this is a first novel!!!
Dec 13, 2010 2:26 PM
Guest :
Excelent---as was Dianes debut novel. Were I a Reviewer this would be an easy review to write; nothing but superlatives.!!!
Mar 16, 2011 6:47 PM
Guest :
Great book,I noticed the topic of three's was very prevalent, see for yourself, 3 girls, 3 members in margaret's family...
36 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement